first posted 27 October 2010
It turns out that the oft-ridiculed film “Reefer Madness” may contain a grain of truth for a small subset of young marijuana users. The original 1938 film was entitled “Tell Your Children”, and, indeed, that is exactly what researchers now recommend for kids who intend to use marijuana. New and ongoing research has shown conclusively that marijuana use in adolescence raises the risk of developing a psychotic illness like schizophrenia. The earlier in life marijuana is used, the higher the risk. A New Zealand study of 1000 people followed from birth to age 26 found that 10% of those who used cannabis before age 15 became schizophrenic versus only 3% of people who rarely, if ever, tried marijuana before age 18.
The evidence for the cannabis-psychosis connection has been building in the medical literature for years. Two studies of siblings published this year (one in Australia, the other in the Netherlands and Belgium) provided the strongest data yet; by using full siblings brought up in the same home, these studies eliminated many of the confounding variables found in other studies. Although researchers stop short of saying that marijuana causes psychotic illness, they are now certain that it is one of the risk factors contributing to these diseases. Theresa Moore and colleagues wrote in a 2007 issue of the British medical journal, The Lancet: “there is now sufficient evidence to warn young people that using cannabis could increase their risk of developing a psychotic illness later in life.” Researchers from the UK and New Zealand comment “Policy makers and law makers should concentrate on delaying onset of cannabis use.”
Heavy users and those whose use extends for a long time also increase their risk of developing psychosis. People who have used cannabis 50 or more times are six times more likely to develop schizophrenia than are non-users. The 2010 sibling study in Australia and another related study showed that those who used marijuana for six years or longer were at significantly higher risk of having psychotic symptoms or developing a psychotic illness than those who used cannabis for a shorter period of time. This study found that, when two siblings both use cannabis, the one who has used it for the longest time is at higher risk of psychosis.
Young people who start life at higher risk of developing a psychotic illness are more sensitive to cannabis and its psychotic effects. Who is at risk? a) children with mentally ill family members; b) those who have experienced prenatal or childhood trauma; c) anyone who has a temporary psychotic reaction (hallucinations, delusions, distorted thinking) when using marijuana; and d) people who live in cities. The 2010 Holland-Belgium study of siblings showed that people with a genetic risk for psychosis are more sensitive to the psychosis-inducing effects of marijuana, and the combination of genetic risk and cannabis use can lead to psychotic illness. Finally, researchers have found that marijuana use in people already diagnosed with psychotic illness worsens their symptoms.
Some evidence shows that a first psychotic episode in users is associated with higher potency cannabis. The potency of marijuana (concentration of delta-9-THC) in the U.S. has increased over time. It went from 1.5% in 1980, to about 3% in 1983-1992, to 4.5% in 1997, and to 9.6% in 2007.
Past misinformation and scare tactics about marijuana led Baby Boomers and following generations to dismiss almost any negative news about the drug. As parents, this group tended not to worry about marijuana use in their children. Since it’s true that most people can use marijuana without serious consequences, why make such a big deal about the small number of young people who may be tipped toward schizophrenia by cannabis? If you are the kid who starts hearing voices, whose thoughts become twisted and non-sensical, who believes you’re being followed by the police...if you are the parent who watches a bright, social child disappear into the darkness, whose hopeful dreams for your offspring’s future are crushed...if you are one of these people, the link between marijuana and psychosis matters.
Family members attending a NAMI (National Alliance for the Mentally Ill) support group admitted to starting out fairly lackadaisical about their children using marijuana. However, most of them now tie marijuana to the initial decline in mental health they saw in their kids. Many of the NAMI parents suspected that their children were “self-medicating” with marijuana. A 2010 British Journal of Pharmacology paper definitively states that there is “overwhelming” lack of evidence for the self-medication hypothesis. While studies have shown that marijuana use is not a risk factor for having depression and anxiety, researchers cannot rule out the possibility that some youngsters may use marijuana to self-medicate for these illnesses.
Millions of Americans use marijuana despite its illegal status: 14.4 million had used it in the month before being questioned in a 2007 survey. Sixty-two percent of the 2.1 million new users each year are under 18. A global 2008 study by the World Health Organization showed that the U.S. and New Zealand had the highest rates of kids under 15 using marijuana. Interestingly, by 21 years, 54% of Americans had used marijuana while only 35% of people in the Netherlands, where cannabis is decriminalized, had. Wikipedia reports that the percentage of people who had used cannabis in the last year was twice as high (12.6%) in the U.S. as in the Netherlands (6.1%). Overall, the U.S. has the highest rates of both legal and illegal drug use in the world.
Update from the scientific literature (Oct. 2017): https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/link-between-adolescent-pot-smoking-and-psychosis-strengthens/
Another update (May 2018): https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/posteverything/wp/2018/05/25/feature/legalizing-marijuana-is-fine-but-dont-ignore-the-science-on-its-dangers/?utm_term=.a06c48b750f3
Yet another update (Jan. 2019): https://www.nytimes.com/2019/01/17/health/cannabis-marijuana-schizophrenia.html
Susie
ReplyDeletemy step son from my former life back in England started having major psychotic episodes on an annual basis when he was 18. Fortunately we the family, and most of the health workers who treated him, got our responses right, so that the second episode was less severe than the first, while the third and final was less severe again. He has now been clear for 6 years and we all believe he has (narrowly) avoided schizophrenia
We all understood at the time that his heavy use of potent and impure marijuana (skunk) was what lead an 18 year old with identity issues to go psychotic. He himself came to understand that, which is why he completely gave it up.
SO - I agree 100% with everything you wrote.
I'd add that at the time (2002) the health workers were saying that in their personal experiences this was especially a problem for adolescent young men - I don't know whether subsequent research indicates any gender effect.
John Waller
Wonderful article and beautiful blog! I'm so proud of you...joining the world of technology and blogging. Way to go, Mom!
ReplyDeleteLove, Molly
Thank you for posting this important information. I only hope that our children heed the advice that this information so clearly gives: using marijuana is dangerous and can potentially exacerbate the risks of psychosis and mental illness.
ReplyDeleteI've talked to my 17-year-old daughter about the known risks associated with marijuana use. While I'm confident that she is not using, I know that her friends are. When I ask if they understand how dangerous it can be, she says that kids her age are going to experiment no matter what the risk because they don't believe it's dangerous. They think that nothing is going to happen to them. They think they are immortal.
I fear for these children and others, and I hope somehow we can get them to understand the personal cost of careless risk before they become ill.
Thank you Suse for a great read. I have a first hand experience with a daughter, Amy, who used some marijuana at age 17 and spent the last 12 years in crises with the mental health systems
ReplyDeletein San Francisco and here in Santa Cruz. She died of an overdose of her meds. and crack. We
can believe the evidence of a quick departure from reality and journey into Schizophrenia.
Suse you got that right. Doug Gallagher
Hi Suse -
ReplyDeleteI think that you're really on target. I haven't followed the marijuana research as you
have, but I wouldn't be surprised if warnings were eventually issued to people using
the drug well beyond the age of 21. I suffered a terrible breakdown one night at the
age of 37, lasting over a year, triggered by marijuana. This was after perhaps half a
year of recreational use, characterized by some euphoria and a sense of greatly
enhanced intuition and creativity in thought. But that night, I tumbled into a swamp
of terror and inner dread, which was rather like a perpetual panic attack with lots
of fractured and distorted thinking and paranoia about myself, though not regarding
the outer world, oddly enough. Lots of struggle, therapy and medication got me
back on track. A battle hard-won. I was almost certainly one of those you would
describe as "at risk" in my youth: strong childhood trauma, having one parent who
suffered a protracted mental illness, and the other an insecure narcissist who
thought he was god's gift on wheels. I can easily imagine that any one, young
or old, who is in the "highly sensitive" end of the curve, or "high strung", as they
used to say, could be at risk using such drugs.
The only way I can see marijuana benefiting those
at risk is if they were in well planned environments, with sympathetic and seasoned guides
and teachers available.
Star and I appreciate your thoughtful research.
Cheers,
Gene
This information on marijuana is something I've had no direct experience with. I'm intrigued and am concerned for the young people today who may use the drug. I'd like to see this be included in the on-going conversation about marijuana use. This is really important for any of us to know, and your rationale for voting yes on Prop 19 are compelling...thank you, Suse!
ReplyDeleteThe legalization of alcohol to those 21 and older doesn't seem to discourage binge drinking among those under 21 so why would it discourage marijuana use among the younger age group. Looking back at my friends use of pot in the late 60s I imagine that there still would have been plenty of parties with underage pot smokers (older siblings, friends, etc. would have been a ready source, not to mention supplies that would exist in the homes of parents who actively used the drug) in the same way as underage drinkers. Some of my former friends who smoked pot back then still do today. In fact, I know a Harvard MD, Ph'D with a stellar track record in the medical field who smokes pot. I think it helps her with anxiety. Her younger brother, whom I used to date, also smokes and is a highly unmotivated but a responsible person. The idea of trying to define it as an adult drug seems ludicrous. Is there an example of how this has been done to date with other drugs? In what areas have public health campaigns been successful? Clearly in the arena of smoking tobacco because many people have clearly grasped the health risks, and the opportunities to smoke in public have diminished dramatically. The big health risks of smoking pot are fairly limited to a small subset of the population, people at risk for psychosis, and no one knows who they are, unless they have undergone genetic testing that has established that connection. In spite of the research to the contrary I think people who drink or smoke pot more than casually do it to self medicate. So the real issue is mental health. Why can't the risks be addressed whether pot is legal or not? I think your argument that legalizing it would control potency might or might not be successful. People who are really into pot tend to like particular types from what I gather. On the other hand people would probably be relieved to know it wasn't laced with something else. Clearly laws prohibiting its use have not discouraged it, but making it more socially acceptable also seems crazy. The idea of going to a social event and hanging around with people toking up is really unappealing. I totally agree with your fifth point about incarcerating people for using it. That is totally nuts. The taxing idea is quite creative and at this point in our economic history might have some great benefits. The way Europeans enjoy alcohol is a great model (kids grow up having a bit of wine at dinner so it doesn't seem to be a big deal when they get older) but I can't imagine that working with pot. The fact that THC induces temporary psychosis in healthy people is a red flag. I absolutely believe that my mentally ill son's drug use contributed to his schizophrenia (at the same time he was self medicating for depression which we didn't recognize; recognizing the signs of adolescent depression and addressing it successfully might be the key; harder said than done), and pot was his main drug of choice, although hallucinogenic mushrooms and stimulants must have also played a role. His symptoms emerged when he had been drug free for a number of months. It would be great if we could have a public campaign scaring people into being afraid to smoke pot based on potential psychosis but for so many people it doesn't play out that way, so how could it be credible?
ReplyDeleteAnyway, you raise a number of important points and questions. Maybe education is a big part of the answer. Don't know if it would have prevented my son's tragedy.
Cannabis does NOT cause psychosis or schizophrenia, these studies are bogus.
ReplyDelete20 June 2018 from The Week: Canada's Senate passed a bill legalizing recreational marijuana use on Tuesday. The 52-29 vote made Canada the second country in the world to approve the creation of a legal marijuana market. Uruguay legalized the production, sale, and use of marijuana in 2013. Canada's House of Commons approved the measure in November, making the Senate vote the bill's final hurdle. The Cannabis Act stemmed from Prime Minister Justin Trudeau's campaign promise to keep marijuana away from children. After the Senate vote, Trudeau tweeted that the law would allow the government to regulate marijuana and keep it away from kids. "It's been too easy for our kids to get marijuana - and for criminals to reap the profits. Today, we change that," Trudeau tweeted. [CNN]. NOTE THAT CANADA IS EMPHASIZING THE RISK TO CHILDREN WHICH IS SOMETHING THAT HAS BEEN MISSING WHEN U.S. STATES HAVE LEGALIZED MARIJUANA.
ReplyDelete